KernelNewbies
  • Comments
  • Immutable Page
  • Menu
    • Navigation
    • RecentChanges
    • FindPage
    • Local Site Map
    • Help
    • HelpContents
    • HelpOnMoinWikiSyntax
    • Display
    • Attachments
    • Info
    • Raw Text
    • Print View
    • Edit
    • Load
    • Save
  • Login

Kernel Hacking

  • Frontpage

  • Kernel Hacking

  • Kernel Documentation

  • Kernel Glossary

  • FAQ

  • Found a bug?

  • Kernel Changelog

  • Upstream Merge Guide

Projects

  • KernelJanitors

  • KernelMentors

  • KernelProjects

Community

  • Why a community?

  • Regional Kernelnewbies

  • Personal Pages

  • Upcoming Events

References

  • Mailing Lists

  • Related Sites

  • Programming Links

Wiki

  • Recent Changes

  • Site Editors

  • Side Bar

  • Tips for Editors

  • Hosted by WikiWall

Navigation

  • RecentChanges
  • FindPage
  • HelpContents

Upload page content

You can upload content for the page named below. If you change the page name, you can also upload content for another page. If the page name is empty, we derive the page name from the file name.

File to load page content from
Page name
Comment

Revision 1 as of 2006-04-19 20:09:24
KernelNewbies:
  • FAQ
  • DoWhile0

Why do a lot of #defines in the kernel use do { ... } while(0)?

There are a couple of reasons:

  • (from Dave Miller) Empty statements give a warning from the compiler so this is why you see #define FOO do { } while(0).

  • (from Dave Miller) It gives you a basic block in which to declare local variables.

  • (from Ben Collins) It allows you to use more complex macros in conditional code. Imagine a macro of several lines of code like:

    #define FOO(x) \
            printf("arg is %s\n", x); \
            do_something_useful(x);
    Now imagine using it like:
    if (blah == 2)
            FOO(blah);
    This interprets to:
    if (blah == 2)
            printf("arg is %s\n", blah);
            do_something_useful(blah);;

    As you can see, the if then only encompasses the printf(), and the do_something_useful() call is unconditional (not within the scope of the if), like you wanted it. So, by using a block like do { ... } while(0), you would get this:

    if (blah == 2)
            do {
                    printf("arg is %s\n", blah);
                    do_something_useful(blah);
            } while (0);
    Which is exactly what you want.
  • (from Per Persson) As both Miller and Collins point out, you want a block statement so you can have several lines of code and declare local variables. But then the natural thing would be to just use for example:

    #define exch(x,y) { int tmp; tmp=x; x=y; y=tmp; }

    However that wouldn't work in some cases. The following code is meant to be an if-statement with two branches:

    if (x > y)
            exch(x,y);          // Branch 1
    else  
            do_something();     // Branch 2

    But it would be interpreted as an if-statement with only one branch:

    if (x > y) {                // Single-branch if-statement!!!
            int tmp;            // The one and only branch consists
            tmp = x;            // of the block.
            x = y;
            y = tmp;
    }
    ;                           // empty statement
    else                        // ERROR!!! "parse error before else"
            do_something();

    The problem is the semi-colon (;) coming directly after the block. The solution for this is to sandwich the block between do and while (0). Then we have a single statement with the capabilities of a block, but not considered as being a block statement by the compiler. Our if-statement now becomes:

    if (x > y)
            do {
                    int tmp;
                    tmp = x;
                    x = y;
                    y = tmp;
            } while(0);
    else
            do_something();
  • MoinMoin Powered
  • Python Powered
  • GPL licensed
  • Valid HTML 4.01